Tuesday, November 18, 2008

You're either with us or against us

Joseph, veteran political speech analyst, is asked by an interviewer whether Barack Obama will be different from George Bush.

...

Joseph: If you look at the speeches they make, you see differences. George Bush uses a lot of the first person: “ I will not yield; I will not rest; I will not relent in waging this struggle for freedom and security.”


Interviewer: Whereas Barack Obama…?


Joseph: Barack Obama uses “We” a lot. “We face a lot of problems.”


Interviewer: So this shows a difference in style? George Bush tends to be unilateral, Barack Obama, multilateral?


Joseph: Definitely. And there’s another defining characteristic between them. George Bush, talking about terrorism, used the expression, “You’re either with us or against us.” It’s a polarizing expression. Black vs. white. No room in the middle for maneouvering.


Interviewer: Or dialogue presumably.


Joseph: Right. A zero tolerancy approach. Hard power. Barack Obama, on the other hand, is a proponent of soft power. It’s a multinational world. “I will listen to you, especially when we disagree.”


Interviewer: The speechmaker molds the leader we see?


Joseph: Partly. But an authoritarian, polarizing approach can also be a reflection of an insecure leader. They put up false dilemmas. Either… or… The secure leader listens and synthesizes. 

...

No comments: